Our editors independently researched the best products online to produce this list. We may receive commission on purchases made from the links below but this will never affect our product choices. Click here to read our disclosure.
Selecting the best innerspring mattress is crucial for those who prioritize support and durability in their sleep experience. Innerspring mattresses are known for their traditional construction, featuring a core of steel coils that provide excellent support and bounce, making them ideal for various sleeping positions. In 2024, the market offers a wide range of innerspring mattresses designed to cater to different comfort preferences, body types, and budget considerations. This guide will help you navigate the top innerspring mattresses available, highlighting their key features and benefits to ensure you find the perfect fit for your sleep needs.
In this guide, we’ll explore the best innerspring mattresses of 2024, focusing on essential factors such as coil count, firmness, materials, and overall durability. Whether you prefer a plush top for added cushioning or a firmer feel for support, this guide covers a variety of options tailored to different sleeping styles, including side, back, and stomach sleepers. We’ll also assess important features like motion isolation, edge support, and warranty options to help you make an informed decision. By comparing these top-rated innerspring mattresses, you can find the ideal option that delivers both comfort and long-lasting support for a restful night’s sleep.
How We Compared The Mattresses
To compare the mattresses, we first looked at the material composition of each mattress, examining the type and quality of foam, innerspring, and other materials used. We also paid attention to the specific technologies employed in the design, such as memory foam, gel infusions, or pocketed springs. We took into consideration any special features each mattress offered, including cooling technology, edge support, and motion isolation. It was essential for us to understand how the combination of these materials and technologies influenced the overall comfort, support, and sleep experience.
Next, we assessed the level of firmness of each mattress, as this is a critical factor in determining suitability for different sleepers. The firmness level of a mattress can impact the comfort and support it provides to individuals with different body types, weights, and sleeping positions. We evaluated each mattress by sleeping on it for several nights, taking note of its performance across various criteria. Additionally, we took into consideration customer reviews and ratings, looking for commonalities and patterns in the feedback. We also factored in price points, warranty periods, and other important purchase considerations to give a well-rounded comparison and help potential buyers make an informed decision.
How To Choose an Innerspring Mattress
When choosing the perfect innerspring mattress, understanding your specific sleep needs is essential. Factors like comfort preferences, sleep position, body weight, health concerns, and budget all play significant roles in making the right choice. For example, side sleepers might prefer a softer mattress to relieve pressure on their shoulders and hips, while back or stomach sleepers might require a firmer surface for proper spinal alignment. Heavier individuals may benefit from a thicker coil gauge for enhanced support and durability, and those with back pain or allergies should consider mattresses with targeted support or hypoallergenic materials. A clear idea of your sleep needs will guide you toward a mattress that suits your personal comfort and health requirements.
The technology behind innerspring mattresses, especially the coil system, is crucial for providing comfort and support. Different types of coils, such as pocketed, continuous, or Bonnell coils, each offer unique advantages. Pocketed coils are individually wrapped to provide body contouring and reduce motion transfer, while continuous coils offer durability with fewer parts. Bonnell coils provide a traditional feel with reliable support. Additionally, the coil gauge determines the firmness; a lower gauge indicates thicker, firmer coils. Understanding these details about coil technology will help ensure you choose a mattress that balances support, comfort, and longevity.
Firmness is another critical factor when selecting an innerspring mattress. A firmness rating typically ranges from soft (1) to firm (10), and choosing the right level depends on your comfort and support preferences. Firm mattresses offer excellent support for the spine and are often more durable, but they may feel too rigid for some sleepers, especially those who prefer a plush, cushioned feel. Finding the ideal balance between support and comfort is key to ensuring restful sleep, so it’s worth testing out different firmness levels to discover what suits your body best.
Innerspring mattresses excel in support, thanks to their coil construction, but coil count and gauge should be considered for optimal performance. A high coil count generally offers better support and weight distribution, while a thicker (lower gauge) coil provides firmer support, enhancing durability. Edge support is another vital feature to look for, as it ensures a stable, supportive surface across the mattress, even when sitting or sleeping near the edge. These factors combine to create a mattress that offers superior comfort, durability, and overall sleep quality.
Finally, breathability and durability are essential for long-term comfort. Innerspring mattresses typically allow better airflow than all-foam models, helping to regulate temperature and keep you cool at night. To ensure longevity, look for mattresses with reinforced edges and a solid construction, and consider maintenance tips like rotating the mattress regularly. If allergies are a concern, hypoallergenic materials can create a healthier sleep environment by resisting dust mites and other allergens. By paying attention to these aspects, you can choose an innerspring mattress that provides years of supportive, comfortable sleep.
The Best Innerspring Mattresses In Detail
Linenspa 10 Inch
The Linenspa 10 Inch is an excellent choice for those seeking a medium feel mattress combining the support of innerspring with memory foam comfort.
Pros
- Responsive hybrid design for the best of both worlds
- Unbeatable value and durable materials for long-lasting comfort
- Direct shipping and easy setup
Cons
- May require up to 72 hours to fully regain its shape
- Heavier than some other mattress options
- The edges may not provide as much support as some sleepers prefer
We recently tried the Linenspa 10 Inch mattress, and we were quite impressed with its unique combination of steel coils and memory foam. This results in a mattress that offers both the contouring comfort of memory foam and the durable, bouncy feel of traditional innerspring.
Setting up the mattress was easy, as it arrived directly to our door, shipped in a compact box. While it did take some time for the mattress to regain its full shape, within 72 hours, it was ready for use. The mattress has a medium feel, with multiple supportive layers providing a good balance of softness and firmness.
One thing we did notice was that the edges could have been a bit more supportive. Some sleepers might feel like they are slipping off the bed when lying close to the edge. However, this is a minor issue for the majority of sleepers who tend to remain in the center of the mattress.
Overall, the Linenspa 10 Inch mattress offers excellent value and comfort for a variety of sleepers. We highly recommend this mattress for anyone seeking a well-rounded sleep experience at an affordable price.
Best Price Mattress 8 Inch Tight Top
We recommend this mattress for those seeking a durable, medium-firm option with a good balance of comfort and support.
Pros
- Comfortable high-density foam top layer
- Supportive and durable bonnell spring base
- CertiPUR-US certified foam ensures safety and quality
Cons
- Might be too firm for some individuals
- Heavy, which could make it more difficult to move or rotate
- Tight top fabric cover not removable for cleaning
This Best Price Mattress 8-Inch Tight Top Innerspring Mattress provides a pleasant sleeping experience for those in need of a medium firm mattress. The high-density foam top layer adds a cushioning element for enhanced comfort, while the bonnell spring base ensures a stable, supportive foundation. Our nights on this mattress felt restful, and we appreciated the even distribution of support it provided, making it easier to change positions throughout the night.
We found the tight top jacquard fabric cover to be smooth and appealing. The microfiber padding on the cover also contributes to the overall comfort and aesthetics of the mattress. However, we noticed that the fabric cover cannot be removed for cleaning, which could be a downside for those who prioritize mattress hygiene.
The mattress is on the heavier side, which may make it difficult to maneuver when it’s time to rotate or move it. It’s worth noting that this mattress is delivered as a bed-in-a-box, making its initial setup quite convenient. The 10-year manufacturer’s warranty also provides peace of mind for potential buyers. Overall, the Best Price Mattress 8 Inch Tight Top Innerspring Mattress is a great option for those seeking a durable, medium firm mattress that prioritizes both comfort and support.
Avenco 12 Inch
The Avenco Queen Mattress is an excellent choice for those seeking a medium-firm innerspring mattress with a cooling touch and noise absorption.
Pros
- Skin-friendly cool touch Tencel fabric
- High-density foam for noise absorption and airflow
- Individual pocket spring system with motion isolation
Cons
- May have a chemical smell upon arrival
- Takes 24-72 hours to fully expand
- Potential for overheating, despite its cooling design
The Avenco Queen Mattress offers a comfortable sleeping experience with its combination of memory foam and pocket innersprings. We found the Tencel fabric to be skin-friendly and cool to the touch, providing a pleasant sensation throughout the night. Moreover, the high-density foam processed with bamboo charcoal makes this mattress well-ventilated, while also helping to absorb noise for a peaceful sleep.
In addition to the comfort provided by the foam layers, the individual pocket spring system of the Avenco mattress ensures optimal support and minimal motion transfer. This means that even if your partner tosses and turns during the night, you won’t be disturbed. Additionally, this mattress is CertiPUR-US certified, making it a safe choice for all sleepers, including pregnant women and children.
On the flip side, we noticed the mattress may have a chemical smell upon arrival. However, this odor tends to dissipate within a few days. Also, keep in mind that it can take up to 72 hours for the mattress to fully expand after unboxing. Lastly, despite the cooling design of the Avenco mattress, some users may still experience overheating while sleeping.
Overall, the Avenco Queen Mattress is a reliable medium-firm option for those seeking a innerspring mattress with cooling features and motion isolation. Just be prepared for a break-in period to allow for full expansion and odor dissipation.
Molblly Mattress, 14-inch
A great choice for those seeking the perfect balance of comfort and support in an innerspring mattress, we highly recommend this Molblly Queen Mattress.
Pros
- Individually pocketed coils for excellent body contouring and motion isolation
- Comfortable surface with plush fabric for a skin-friendly touch
- Strong edge support and reinforced foam
Cons
- Might be too soft for those looking for a firm mattress
- Unwrapping process can be tricky
- Takes 72 hours to fully air out and reshape
The Molblly Queen Mattress offers a comfortable and supportive sleep experience with its individually wrapped pocket coils. We found these to provide consistent distribution of support throughout the mattress, while also minimizing motion transfer between sleep partners. The comfortable surface is covered with a plush fabric that is not only soft to the touch but also skin-friendly.
The support system of the Molblly mattress is a standout feature. We appreciated the tempered steel coil system which provides powerful support to every part of the body (feet, legs, hips, waist, shoulders, neck, and head) and caters well to the spine’s alignment. The tightly knit edges and reinforced foam maximize edge support and overall durability.
One downside we experienced was the unwrapping process, which could be difficult due to the clear plastic wrapping, making it hard to see where to cut. The mattress does come with a cutting tool, but caution is required during this stage. Additionally, it’s recommended to allow 72 hours for the mattress to air out and reshape fully before use.
Overall, we believe the Molblly Queen Mattress is an excellent choice for those seeking a comfortable, supportive, and well-rounded innerspring mattress. It offers the perfect balance of comfort and support, with the added bonus of motion isolation and edge support.
SUAYEA Mattress
This SUAYEA Queen Mattress offers an affordable, comfortable sleeping experience suited for those seeking medium-firm support with ultimate motion isolation.
Pros
- Excellent motion isolation for undisturbed sleep
- Comfortable and luxurious top layer
- Solid edge support for even weight distribution
Cons
- May require a topper for personalized comfort
- Needs 24-72 hours to fully expand
- Some may find it slightly noisy
We recently tried out the SUAYEA Queen Mattress and were quite impressed by its performance, especially considering the affordable price point. The combination of pocketed springs and high-density foam provides ultimate motion isolation, ensuring a good night’s sleep without disturbances.
The top layer of the mattress is made of skin-friendly fabric and three layers of high-density foam, creating a luxurious and cozy sleeping surface. Despite its comfortable feel, some may prefer to add a topper for a personalized sleep experience.
One of the standout features of this mattress is its solid edge support, thanks to the strong pocketed springs surrounding it. This prevents sagging and ensures a longer-lasting lifespan for your mattress. However, certain individuals may notice a slight noise from the springs when moving on the bed.
All in all, the SUAYEA Queen Mattress is an excellent choice for anyone looking for medium-firm support and ultimate motion isolation at an affordable price. Just make sure to give it ample time to expand before use and consider a topper if you prefer a more customized comfort level.
Rimensy Mattress
We recommend the Rimensy mattress as a comfortable and supportive option for your new innerspring mattress.
Pros
- Excellent combination of gel memory foam and individually wrapped coils
- Unique, breathable cover and airy mesh for optimal temperature regulation
- Motion isolation and minimized noise for undisturbed sleep
Cons
- May take up to 72 hours to fully expand
- Slightly heavier than other mattresses at 69.9 pounds
- Medium firmness might not suit everybody’s preference
The Rimensy mattress proved to be a delightful sleeping experience for us. The ultimate bedtime experience is achieved by combining cooling gel memory foam with individually wrapped pocket coils. These materials work together to provide both support and pressure relief, ensuring a good night’s sleep without waking up to any discomfort or body aches.
One notable feature of this mattress is its unique cool cover. Made from dual-layered soft knitted fabrics that are extremely breathable, this cover keeps the mattress feeling cool and comfortable throughout the night. The reinforced foam also offers excellent edge support, contributing to its overall high-quality design.
While sleeping on the Rimensy mattress, we appreciated the motion isolation provided by the innerspring base with eight separate support zones. Each coil reacts to movement individually, reducing motion transfer and minimizing noise made by a partner’s movements. This ensures that anyone sharing the bed will enjoy a peaceful and uninterrupted slumber.
On the downside, you’ll have to wait for up to 72 hours after unwrapping the mattress for it to return to its full shape. Also, it’s important to keep a safe distance during the unwrapping process, as there’s a risk of it smacking you while expanding. Furthermore, this mattress has a medium firmness level, which means it may not be the perfect choice for all sleepers.
In conclusion, the Rimensy mattress impressed us with its comfort, support, and motion isolation. The breathable cover and unique design make it a great option for anyone seeking a new innerspring mattress. Although there are a few minor drawbacks, we believe this mattress is a worthy purchase for a restful and refreshing sleeping experience.
MLILY EGOHOME Mattress
The MLILY EGOHOME 12 Inch Queen Mattress is an excellent choice for those seeking a comfortable and supportive innerspring mattress with innovative cooling technology.
Pros
- Suitable for all sleep positions
- Graphene technology cover for added benefits
- CertiPUR-US certified
Cons
- May need 2 hours to fully expand after unboxing
- No trial period, opened mattresses cannot be returned
- Might be too firm for some preferences
We were impressed by the MLILY EGOHOME 12 Inch Queen Mattress as it provided a medium-firm feel that caters to a wide range of sleepers and sleep positions. The cooling gel memory foam contributes to a cooler night’s sleep, making it perfect for hot sleepers. Moreover, the graphene technology cover offers added therapeutic benefits, such as promoting blood circulation and regulating moisture, odor, and temperature for a dry and breathable sleep environment.
The mattress is made in the USA and has been certified by CertiPUR-US for safety, durability, performance, emissions, and content. It has also received the International Chiropractors Association’s endorsement, making it ideal for achieving a healthier sleep lifestyle.
However, there are a few potential drawbacks to consider. Upon unboxing, the mattress may need up to 2 hours to fully expand to its original shape, which might be an inconvenience for some users. Additionally, there is no trial period, and opened mattresses cannot be returned. Lastly, although the medium-firm feel suits most sleepers, some people may find it too firm or uncomfortable for their preferences.
In conclusion, if you are looking for a high-quality innerspring mattress that offers both comfort and support with innovative cooling technology, the MLILY EGOHOME 12 Inch Queen Mattress is a great option to consider. However, keep in mind the firmness level and the return policy before making a purchase.
Olee Sleep 13-inch Galaxy
Considering the Olee Sleep 13-inch Galaxy Mattress for a comfortable and supportive sleep with temperature regulation and motion isolation.
Pros
- Comfortable memory foam with I-Gel cooling technology
- Pocket springs provide strong support and motion isolation
- High-quality materials with safety certifications
Cons
- Might be too firm for those who prefer a softer bed
- May require 72 hours for full expansion after opening
- Heavy at 83.77 pounds, making it difficult to move
The Olee Sleep 13-inch Galaxy Mattress is an impressive choice for those who put value on a comfortable yet supportive night’s sleep. The mattress features a combination of pocket springs and memory foam layers, which ensures good support for your back, hips, and neck. We particularly appreciated that the high-quality I-Gel foam adjusts to the body shape, providing customized comfort and effectively dispersing body temperature during sleep.
One aspect that we were not too fond of was the mattress’s firmness. It might be a little too firm for some people’s preferences. However, keep in mind that firmness is subjective and varies from person to person. On a positive note, the pocket spring design of the mattress does an excellent job at isolating motion, ensuring minimal disturbance for partners sharing the bed.
Another thing to be aware of when purchasing this mattress is the time it takes to fully expand. You will need to let it rest in room temperature for 72 hours after unboxing to reach its full height and firmness. Additionally, the mattress is quite heavy at 83.77 pounds, which can make it challenging to move and set up.
In conclusion, the Olee Sleep 13-inch Galaxy Mattress offers a fantastic combination of comfort, support, and temperature regulation. Though slightly on the firmer side and a tad heavy, it’s a great option for anyone who prioritizes a restful and undisturbed sleep.
