Top 8 Soft Mattresses Reviewed for 2024

Our editors independently researched the best products online to produce this list. We may receive commission on purchases made from the links below but this will never affect our product choices. Click here to read our disclosure.

---

When it comes to mattresses, we often hear about the popular firm ones. However, on the opposite end of the spectrum, soft mattresses have their own loyal following. They can also be referred to as plush, pillow top, or eurotop, each with its own unique style. Soft mattresses have their advantages, but like any product, they may not suit everyone’s preferences.

In our soft mattress reviews, we will explore the characteristics that set them apart from firmer options, aside from just the level of firmness. Additionally, we will recommend eight of the best soft mattresses available at various price points. Whether you’re seeking luxurious comfort or a cloud-like sleeping experience, our reviews will help you find the perfect soft mattress for your needs.

How We Compared The Mattresses

When evaluating the best soft mattresses, we considered factors like comfort, support, materials, and durability. Comfort is key when it comes to soft mattresses, so we evaluated aspects such as the softness of the top layer, the quality of pressure relief, and how well the mattress conforms to the body.

Support is another essential factor as a soft mattress still needs to provide adequate support to maintain proper spinal alignment. We looked at how each mattress balanced softness with support.

Materials used in the mattress can greatly impact both comfort and durability. We looked for high-quality foams, latex, or innerspring units that offer a soft feel but also hold up over time.

Durability is crucial as softer materials can sometimes wear out more quickly. We considered the quality and density of the materials used, along with the construction of the mattress.

Finally, we considered customer reviews to gain insight into how each mattress performs in real-world scenarios, and we evaluated the warranty and sleep trial periods offered by each manufacturer. By focusing on these factors, we identified the best soft mattresses available on the market.

How To Choose The Best Soft Mattress

When selecting the best soft mattress, comfort and support are crucial, especially if you’re seeking a cozy and restful sleep. Soft mattresses are ideal for sleepers who prefer a plush surface that contours to their body, providing a cradling effect. However, not all soft mattresses are created equal, and finding the right one involves considering various factors such as your sleeping position, body weight, and personal preferences. By evaluating these aspects, you can choose a soft mattress that delivers the perfect balance of cushioning and support to enhance your sleep quality.

For side sleepers, a soft mattress is especially beneficial because it helps reduce pressure on the shoulders and hips. The softness allows your body to sink in slightly, providing pressure relief while maintaining spinal alignment. However, back and stomach sleepers may require a softer mattress with adequate support to prevent their lower back from sinking too far. It’s essential to select a mattress that offers the right balance of plushness and firmness based on your sleep style to avoid discomfort or misalignment.

Body type and weight are also important when choosing a soft mattress. Heavier individuals may require a mattress that offers both softness and enhanced support to prevent excessive sinking, which could lead to discomfort or poor spinal alignment. Lighter individuals, on the other hand, might find that very soft mattresses offer enough contouring without sacrificing support. Trying out mattresses with different firmness levels and support zones can help you find the perfect fit for your body type.

Motion isolation and temperature control are additional factors to keep in mind when selecting a soft mattress. If you share your bed with a partner, a mattress with good motion isolation can prevent disturbances caused by movement during the night. Mattresses with cooling technologies, such as gel-infused memory foam or breathable latex, can also help regulate body temperature, ensuring you stay cool and comfortable throughout the night.

In conclusion, when choosing the best soft mattress, consider the combination of materials, support, and features that suit your sleeping style, body type, and comfort preferences. A high-quality soft mattress should offer both plush comfort and the necessary support to promote restful sleep. Take the time to explore different options, test them out, and prioritize features like pressure relief, motion isolation, and temperature regulation to ensure a rejuvenating sleep experience.

The Best Soft Mattresses In Detail

Amerisleep AS5

The Amerisleep AS5 is a remarkable memory foam mattress that embodies a luxurious and extraordinary level of softness, offering a sensation of sinking into a cloud. Designed with meticulous attention to detail, this mattress provides a sleep surface that is truly gentle and enveloping.

At the core of the Amerisleep AS5 mattress lies a multi-layered construction that combines softness and support in perfect harmony. The plush top layer creates a distinctively soft surface, while a supportive layer beneath ensures optimal comfort and alignment. This unique combination allows sleepers to experience a perfect balance of plushness and support, providing a truly restful sleep.

One of the standout features of the Amerisleep AS5 is its zoned support layer. This layer is strategically designed to provide targeted back support while allowing for deep compression support. By addressing specific pressure points, such as the hips and shoulders, the mattress relieves pressure and enhances overall comfort. The innovative wave design further contributes to pressure relief, ensuring a more comfortable and rejuvenating sleeping experience.

Another remarkable quality of the Amerisleep AS5 is its minimal motion transfer. This is especially beneficial for couples or individuals who share a bed. The mattress effectively absorbs and isolates motion, preventing disturbances from transferring across the surface. As a result, both sleepers can enjoy uninterrupted sleep throughout the night, undisturbed by movement.

The Amerisleep AS5 is particularly well-suited for side sleepers. Its slow reaction memory foam feel conforms to the body’s contours, cradling the hips and shoulders with gentle support. This level of contouring ensures proper spinal alignment and alleviates pressure points, making it an excellent choice for those who prefer to sleep on their side. Side sleepers can enjoy the benefits of a soft mattress without sacrificing support or waking up with discomfort.

Customer satisfaction with the Amerisleep AS5 is notably high, thanks to its unique contouring properties. The mattress provides just the right amount of sinkage without the feeling of being stuck or trapped, a common concern among memory foam enthusiasts. With the Amerisleep AS5, sleepers can experience the enveloping comfort of memory foam without compromising breathability or overheating issues.

Beyond its exceptional comfort and support, Amerisleep mattresses are built to last. Crafted with high-quality materials and a commitment to durability, the Amerisleep AS5 provides long-lasting performance. This ensures that customers can enjoy the luxurious softness and unparalleled comfort for years to come.

In summary, the Amerisleep AS5 stands as a testament to luxurious softness in the realm of mattresses. With its carefully crafted layers, pressure-relieving design, minimal motion transfer, and compatibility with different sleeping positions, it earns its reputation as the best soft mattress for side sleepers. Experience the perfect balance of plushness and support, and indulge in a restful sleep night after night with the Amerisleep AS5.

Further reading: Check out some more Amerisleep reviews here, including the AS1, AS2 and AS3.

Saatva Classic

When it comes to achieving softness in a mattress without relying on memory foam, latex, or extra coils, the Saatva Classic stands as a testament to excellence. Renowned for its exceptional build and superior support, it remains one of the best-selling soft mattresses available today.

One of the standout features of the Saatva Classic is its ability to deliver a deep and restful sleep experience. Countless individuals have found solace in this mattress, relishing in its extraordinary comfort night after night. The carefully crafted design of the Saatva Classic ensures a truly comfortable sleep surface that promotes relaxation and rejuvenation.

A notable advantage of the Saatva Classic is its ability to minimize motion transfer. Sharing a bed with a partner no longer means sacrificing a peaceful sleep. The mattress effectively absorbs and isolates motion, creating a quiet and undisturbed sleep environment. Whether you live with a spouse, children, or anyone else, the Saatva Classic ensures that both sides of the bed remain calm throughout the night.

The Saatva Classic boasts a firmness level known as Plush Soft. This carefully calibrated firmness level strikes the perfect balance between softness and support, catering to individuals who prefer a more plush sleep surface. Additionally, the Saatva Classic is available in a range of sizes, including Twin, Full, Queen, King, and California King, ensuring that there is an option to fit your bed frame perfectly.

In addition to its remarkable comfort and tailored sizing options, the Saatva Classic offers a host of other benefits. With every purchase, customers receive free white glove delivery, ensuring a hassle-free and convenient setup process. The mattress also comes with a generous 180-night in-home trial, allowing you to experience the exceptional softness and comfort of the Saatva Classic in the comfort of your own home. Furthermore, a 15-year warranty provides peace of mind, assuring that your investment is protected for years to come.

In summary, the Saatva Classic is unmatched when it comes to achieving softness in a mattress without compromising on support. Its exceptional build, minimal motion transfer, and tailored firmness level make it a top choice for those seeking a soft sleep surface. Experience the epitome of comfort and enjoy nights of deep and restful sleep with the Saatva Classic.

Further reading: Find out more about the Soft option of this mattress in our full Saatva Classic review.

Puffy Lux

When it comes to achieving the utmost softness without compromising on support, this medium-plush mattress truly stands out among its peers. Renowned for its exceptional comfort and outstanding customer reviews, it has earned a reputation as one of the softest and best-reviewed mattresses available.

At the heart of this remarkable mattress lies a gel-based memory foam construction that strikes a perfect balance between comfort and support. Despite its softness, it provides excellent balanced support and contouring, ensuring that you experience the ultimate level of comfort while maintaining proper spinal alignment. The top layer features Cooling Cloud Gel, offering a refreshing and cool sleep surface that helps regulate body temperature. Just beneath, the Plush Dual Cloud and Climate Comfort layers work harmoniously to provide additional plushness and comfort. Lastly, the Firm Core Support layer acts as a sturdy base, promoting enhanced spinal alignment and pressure point relief.

Regardless of your preferred sleeping style, whether you’re a back, side, or stomach sleeper, this mattress caters to all. Its adaptive design ensures that you’ll find exceptional comfort and support, regardless of how you choose to sleep. With this mattress, you can comfortably sink into its luxurious softness, knowing that your sleep position is perfectly accommodated.

Like most reputable brands, this mattress is CertiPUR-US Certified, guaranteeing its cleanliness and allergen-free composition. Crafted with high-quality and durable advanced foams, it is designed to withstand the test of time, surpassing many competitors within its price range.

With your purchase, you’ll enjoy the added peace of mind provided by the lifetime warranty. This demonstrates the manufacturer’s commitment to delivering a mattress of exceptional quality and longevity. Furthermore, shipping is free, and the mattress is conveniently compressed and rolled, making it easy to transport and deliver directly to your doorstep.

In summary, this gel-based memory foam mattress offers unparalleled softness and exceptional support. With its multi-layered construction, gel-infused cooling technology, and CertiPUR-US certification, it ensures a sleep experience that is both comfortable and clean. Embrace the softness and sink into a world of sublime comfort, knowing that this mattress is designed to provide years of restful and rejuvenating sleep.

Layla

Layla Sleep is a renowned company with a wealth of expert manufacturing experience, dedicated to delivering exceptional mattresses crafted with natural materials. At the heart of their innovative lineup is the copper-infused memory foam mattress—a true gem that combines the best of both worlds: firmness and softness, all in one. With Layla Sleep, you get the unique advantage of experiencing two different firmness levels within a single mattress, providing incredible value for your investment.

Let’s start with the soft side of this remarkable mattress. When you flip it over and place the soft side up, you’ll be greeted with three inches of sumptuous copper-infused memory foam. This luxurious layer offers a plush and soft feel that gently cradles your body. The infusion of copper within the memory foam brings additional benefits, including impressive heat dissipation capabilities. Copper aids in rapid cooling and efficient transfer of body heat, ensuring that you stay comfortably cool throughout the night, free from uncomfortable night sweats.

Beneath the copper-infused memory foam, you’ll find a two-inch zoned SMT (Surface Modification Technology) layer. This carefully engineered layer provides enhanced comfort and targeted support precisely where you need it the most. It effectively contours to your body, relieving pressure points and promoting proper spinal alignment.

Next in line is the Support Core Foam, which acts as the foundation of the soft side of the mattress. This crucial layer prevents long-term sagging and ensures the longevity and maximum lifespan of the mattress. It provides a solid base that supports the layers above, contributing to the overall durability and stability of the mattress.

Now, let’s explore the firm side of the Layla Sleep mattress. Flip the mattress over, and you’ll discover a one-inch layer of memory foam that is specifically designed for those who prefer a firmer sleep experience. This thin layer of memory foam comes into closer and quicker contact with the Support Core Foam, resulting in a firmer feel. However, for individuals seeking a soft mattress, the firm side serves as an essential foundation, supporting the layers above.

In addition to its incredible comfort and dual-sided design, the copper-infused foam offers remarkable cooling properties. It stands among the best cooling features available in the market, ensuring that your sleep remains cool and comfortable throughout the night. Furthermore, the copper infusion boasts antimicrobial properties, keeping the mattress cleaner and fresher for an extended period.

As with the other exceptional mattresses in the Layla Sleep lineup, this mattress is conveniently compressed, rolled, and vacuum-sealed for shipping. This ensures a hassle-free and straightforward setup process, allowing you to enjoy your new mattress with ease.

In summary, the copper-infused dual-sided wonder by Layla Sleep represents the epitome of exquisite comfort and versatility. With its unique ability to offer two distinct firmness levels within a single mattress, it provides unparalleled value. Indulge in the plush softness of the copper-infused memory foam, or flip it over for a firmer sleeping experience. Embrace the cooling benefits and antimicrobial properties of the copper infusion, and enjoy the convenience of compressed and rolled shipping. With Layla Sleep, you can truly experience the pinnacle of comfort, all in one remarkable mattress.

Further Reading: Check our full Layla mattress review.

Live and Sleep Resort Ultra 12-inch

Live and Sleep presents the Resort Ultra mattress, tailored for individuals yearning for a night’s sleep that feels like resting on a cloud, all while retaining the luxurious sensation of soft memory foam. This mattress is carefully crafted to provide an unparalleled sleep experience with its unique combination of premium materials.

At the topmost layer of the Resort Ultra mattress lies a lavish 2.5-inch thick premium “air-flow” memory foam. This top layer is designed to cradle your body with cloud-like softness, enveloping you in a cocoon of comfort. The innovative air-flow technology incorporated within the memory foam ensures optimal breathability, promoting air circulation to prevent heat buildup and keep you cool throughout the night.

Just beneath the top layer, you’ll find a 1-inch layer of gel-infused foam. This remarkable addition serves to dissipate heat more efficiently than traditional foams. By drawing heat away from your body and distributing it across the mattress, it helps to regulate temperature and create a pleasantly cool sleep environment. Say goodbye to discomfort caused by overheating, and enjoy a blissful night’s sleep.

The substantial base of the Resort Ultra mattress comprises 8.5 inches of high-density polyurethane foam. This layer provides the necessary support to ensure proper spinal alignment and pressure point relief. While the top layers offer luxurious softness, the base foam delivers stability and durability, ensuring long-lasting performance.

Live and Sleep takes pride in their attention to detail, as seen in the soft flex linen cover that adorns the Resort Ultra mattress. This cover adds a touch of elegance and serves as an extra layer of comfort. It complements the high-quality composition of this popular mattress, enhancing the overall sleep experience.

Versatility is a key feature of the Resort Ultra mattress, as it is designed to work seamlessly on various surfaces. Whether you have an adjustable bed, box spring, hardwood floor, or platform bed, this mattress adapts effortlessly to ensure a plush memory foam experience no matter the foundation.

One of the notable advantages of the Resort Ultra mattress is its affordability. Live and Sleep offers this exceptional plush memory foam mattress at a budget-friendly price, making it an excellent option for those seeking luxury at a lower cost.

In summary, the Resort Ultra by Live and Sleep delivers cloud-like comfort and the indulgence of soft memory foam. With its combination of air-flow memory foam, gel-infused foam, and high-density polyurethane base foam, it provides a perfect balance of support and plushness. Enjoy the added touch of elegance with the soft flex linen cover, and experience the versatility of this mattress on various surfaces. Discover a truly restful and rejuvenating sleep experience without breaking the bank.

Zenhaven

Saatva, a leading manufacturer and online retailer in the bed and mattress industry, presents the Zenhaven luxury plush mattress—an epitome of opulence and comfort. Crafted with meticulous attention to detail, this 10-inch all-latex mattress offers an exceptional level of plushness, providing a truly luxurious sleep experience.

At the heart of the Zenhaven mattress lies 100% Talalay processed latex, meticulously chosen for its superior softness and comfort. This all-latex construction ensures a sleep surface that is remarkably plush and inviting. With four layers of zoned natural latex, the Zenhaven mattress delivers unrivaled support and contouring capabilities. Similar to the Layla mattress, this mattress boasts a double-sided design, offering two distinct firmness options. One side is the Luxury-Plush, providing an exceptionally soft bed, while the other side is the Gentle-Firm, offering a firmer sleep experience.

The plush side of the Zenhaven mattress is a haven for those seeking a truly soft and enveloping sleep surface. The latex contours and cradles the body, providing a gentle embrace that relieves pressure points and promotes deep relaxation. The remarkable motion isolation properties of the Zenhaven mattress ensure minimal disturbance from movement, allowing for undisturbed sleep throughout the night. Enhancing the plushness of the mattress is the thick New Zealand wool organic cover, adding an extra layer of softness and luxury.

Concerned about heat retention? Rest assured, the Zenhaven mattress is designed with ventilation in mind. The latex construction includes vents that effectively dissipate heat, preventing uncomfortable heat traps and promoting a cool and refreshing sleep environment. Hot sleepers can enjoy the plushness of the Zenhaven mattress without worrying about overheating.

With the Zenhaven luxury plush mattress, Saatva demonstrates their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. The mattress comes with a 20-year manufacturer’s warranty, offering coverage for any defects or flaws. Please note that the warranty does not cover natural wear and tear. Additionally, Saatva provides a generous 180-day trial period, allowing you to experience the unparalleled plushness of the Zenhaven mattress in the comfort of your own home. As a testament to their commitment to customer service, Saatva offers free white glove delivery anywhere in the continental U.S., ensuring a seamless and convenient experience from start to finish.

In summary, the Zenhaven luxury plush mattress by Saatva offers a level of plushness that is truly unmatched. With its all-latex construction, double-sided design, and New Zealand wool organic cover, it provides a sleep experience that is both indulgent and luxurious. Enjoy the gentle embrace and contouring support of the Zenhaven mattress, knowing that you are supported by Saatva’s commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.

Further reading: For more details check our full Zenhaven review.

Serta Perfect Sleeper

At the forefront of the mattress industry stands Serta, a trusted and globally renowned brand. Their Perfect Sleeper model represents the pinnacle of comfort and innovation. This hybrid mattress seamlessly combines foam layers with individually wrapped springs, offering a sleep experience that is truly exceptional.

The springs in the Serta Perfect Sleeper are individually wrapped, specifically designed to reduce motion transfer and provide unparalleled support. This innovative feature ensures that any movement on one side of the mattress is isolated, preventing disturbances from affecting your sleep. To further enhance the softness, edge support, and noise reduction, the springs are encased in foam. This combination of foam and springs results in a harmonious blend of comfort and support.

The Serta Perfect Sleeper is replete with features and extras that are meticulously crafted to elevate your sleep quality. As a trusted brand with a reputation for technological advancements, Serta offers this mattress at a higher price point compared to other options. However, many buyers find the investment well worth it, recognizing the importance of spending their money where they spend a significant portion of their time—on a high-quality mattress.

One of the standout features of the Serta Perfect Sleeper is its inherent cooling properties. As a hybrid mattress with coils, it already promotes airflow and runs cool. Additionally, the inclusion of a gel layer below the foam layer further dissipates heat, ensuring a consistently cool sleep environment. The foam layer and pocketed springs work in synergy to provide excellent support for side sleepers, relieving pressure points and promoting proper spinal alignment. The pillow top layer adds a touch of luxury, contributing to an indulgent sleep experience. This mattress strikes an ideal balance between soft comfort and firm contouring, catering to a wide range of sleep preferences.

Reduced partner movement impact and roll-off are additional benefits of the Serta Perfect Sleeper. The advanced construction and design of the mattress effectively minimize the effects of partner movement, allowing for uninterrupted sleep. You can rest assured that your sleep will remain undisturbed, even if your partner shifts positions during the night.

In summary, the Serta Perfect Sleeper Hybrid embodies unparalleled comfort and support. With its hybrid design, foam layers, and individually wrapped springs, it offers a sleep experience that surpasses expectations. Embrace the luxurious comfort and advanced features of this mattress, knowing that you are investing in a brand that prioritizes innovation and customer satisfaction.

Brooklyn Bedding Aurora

When discussing soft mattresses, it’s impossible to overlook the remarkable Aurora by Brooklyn Bedding. While the company boasts a long-standing history in mattress manufacturing, they stand out by approaching things differently. The Aurora mattress showcases their commitment to innovation and quality craftsmanship.

One notable aspect of the Aurora mattress is the inclusion of proprietary patented foams, setting it apart from its competitors. The combination of CopperFlex, TitanFlex, and TitanCool foams creates a sleep surface that is truly exceptional. These specially engineered foams work in unison to deliver a luxurious and supportive sleep experience.

Beneath the surface of the Aurora mattress lies an 8-inch base core consisting of up to 1,032 individually encased coils. This coil system contributes to excellent pressure point relief, ensuring that you experience the ultimate comfort and support. Furthermore, the coil system is thoughtfully zoned, providing targeted support to your body’s crucial areas, such as the hips, shoulders, and neck. Despite its softness, the Aurora mattress delivers the necessary support where it is needed most.

In addition to its exceptional construction, the Aurora mattress comes with several customer-centric benefits. Enjoy the convenience of free shipping, ensuring a seamless delivery process to your doorstep. To further guarantee your satisfaction, Brooklyn Bedding offers a 120-night in-home sleep trial, allowing you to experience the plushness and comfort of the Aurora mattress in the comfort of your own home. Rest assured that your investment is protected by a 10-year warranty, providing you with peace of mind and long-lasting support.

In summary, the Aurora by Brooklyn Bedding represents a true embodiment of unrivaled softness and innovation. With its proprietary patented foams, individually encased coil system, and thoughtful zoning, it offers a sleep experience that is truly extraordinary. Indulge in the plushness of the Aurora mattress, knowing that Brooklyn Bedding’s commitment to quality and customer satisfaction is at the forefront of their craftsmanship.