2024’s Best Firm Mattresses: Reviews and Top 6 Comparison

Our editors independently researched the best products online to produce this list. We may receive commission on purchases made from the links below but this will never affect our product choices. Click here to read our disclosure.

---

Selecting the best firm mattress is crucial for those who require extra support for optimal spinal alignment and pressure relief during sleep. Firm mattresses are particularly beneficial for back and stomach sleepers, as they help maintain a neutral spine position and prevent the body from sinking too deeply into the mattress. In 2024, there are numerous options available, including memory foam, innerspring, and hybrid mattresses, each offering varying levels of firmness and support. This comparison guide will help you explore the top firm mattresses on the market, highlighting their key features and benefits to ensure you find the right fit for your sleep preferences.

In this guide, we’ll delve into the best firm mattresses of 2024, focusing on important factors such as materials, durability, temperature regulation, and pricing. Whether you’re looking for a mattress that provides a solid feel or one that balances firmness with a touch of comfort, this guide covers a range of models designed to cater to different sleeping styles and body types. We’ll also evaluate critical features like edge support and motion isolation to help you make an informed decision. By comparing these top-rated firm mattresses, you can find the ideal option that delivers the support you need for a restful night’s sleep.

How We Compared The Mattresses

When comparing firm mattresses, our evaluation focused on the support, durability, and comfort they offer. We studied each mattress’s construction, quality of materials, and firmness, with a focus on medium-firm to firm mattresses. We also considered pressure relief, looking at how well each mattress conformed to the body to alleviate pressure points, with special attention to features like zoning or targeted support.

Durability was another key factor, with the aim of identifying mattresses that can withstand years of use without sagging or indentations. We also looked at practical aspects like noise, edge support, and motion isolation, which firm mattresses often excel at.

Lastly, the terms of each mattress’s warranty and any sleep trial offered were considered as these can offer customers a risk-free buying experience. This evaluation allowed us to identify the best firm mattresses on the market.

How To Pick a Firm Mattress

When it comes to getting a good night’s sleep, choosing the right firm mattress is key. Firm mattresses offer the solid support necessary for maintaining proper spinal alignment, making them ideal for back or stomach sleepers, those with heavier body types, or individuals dealing with back pain. However, finding the best firm mattress can feel overwhelming with so many options available. To simplify the process, it’s essential to focus on factors like support, sleeping position, body type, and additional features that cater to your specific needs.

Support and Comfort should be your top priority when choosing a firm mattress. The mattress needs to provide enough firmness to prevent sagging while supporting your body’s natural alignment. However, it’s important to balance this firmness with a degree of comfort. Firm mattresses with memory foam or latex layers can contour to your body, offering pressure relief at key points like your hips, shoulders, and lower back. Even if a mattress feels solid, it should still cradle your body just enough to promote comfort without sacrificing support. Keep in mind that your sleep preferences—whether you prioritize softness or a firmer sleep surface—will influence your comfort level on a firm mattress.

Your sleeping position is another vital factor. Back sleepers benefit from firm mattresses because they maintain proper spine alignment by preventing the lower back from sinking in too much. Stomach sleepers also need firm support to keep their hips and spine aligned, which prevents discomfort in the lower back. Side sleepers, on the other hand, may require a slightly softer mattress or a firm mattress with good contouring properties to relieve pressure on their shoulders and hips. A firm mattress that provides zoning, with softer areas under pressure points and firmer sections for spinal support, can be an excellent choice for those with specific needs.

Another consideration is your body weight and type, which can greatly affect how a firm mattress feels. Heavier individuals tend to sink further into a mattress, so they usually require a firmer model to avoid too much sinking and to maintain proper support. For those with lighter body weights, a firm mattress can sometimes feel too hard, leading to discomfort. If this is the case, a firm mattress with a top layer of memory foam or a hybrid design can provide the necessary support while still feeling comfortable. For broader shoulders or hips, look for mattresses with customizable zones or targeted support to maintain spinal alignment and relieve pressure in the right places.

Additional features and accessories like temperature regulation and motion isolation are also important. Many modern firm mattresses come equipped with cooling technology, such as gel-infused memory foam or breathable latex, which helps maintain a comfortable temperature throughout the night. This feature is particularly important for hot sleepers who want a firm mattress but also need to avoid overheating. For couples, motion isolation is another critical feature, as it reduces the transfer of movement from one side of the bed to the other, minimizing disturbances during sleep.

Finally, don’t forget about trial periods and warranties. Many brands offer extended trial periods, ranging from 90 to 120 nights, allowing you to test the mattress in your own home. This flexibility is essential, as it ensures you have enough time to determine whether the mattress truly suits your comfort and support needs. Warranties, which can range from 10 to 25 years, provide peace of mind by protecting against premature wear or defects.

The Best Firm Mattresses In Detail

Helix Dawn Luxe

If you appreciate the support and comfort of a firm mattress, the Helix Dawn Luxe is the perfect choice for you. This thoughtfully designed mattress is tailored to meet the needs of individuals who prefer a firmer sleep surface, ensuring a restful and undisturbed night’s sleep.

With its carefully crafted construction, the Helix Dawn Luxe combines three distinct comfort layers to provide exceptional firmness and customization. The top layer features Dynamic foam, followed by a high-grade polyfoam layer and a specialized 1000+ pocket coil layer. This unique combination offers superior support, promoting proper spinal alignment and minimizing pressure points.

What sets Helix apart is their commitment to quality and attention to detail. The team behind Helix understands the importance of a comfortable and rejuvenating sleep experience, and their dedication shines through in the craftsmanship of the Dawn Luxe mattress.

To ensure your complete satisfaction, Helix offers a generous 100-day trial period, allowing you to try the Dawn Luxe mattress in the comfort of your own home. This risk-free trial period gives you the opportunity to determine if the firmness level is perfect for your individual needs. Additionally, the mattress is backed by a 10-15 year warranty, providing long-term peace of mind.

Discover the optimal balance of support and firmness with the Helix Dawn Luxe mattress. Designed to meet the unique preferences of firm mattress lovers, it offers a comfortable and rejuvenating sleep experience that will leave you feeling refreshed and revitalized each morning.

Further reading: Also check our full Helix Midnight Luxe review.

Zinus 12 Inch Performance Plus – Extra Firm

For those seeking the ultimate in firmness, the Zinus Performance Plus mattress stands out as the best choice. With its unique combination of foam and pocketed springs, this mattress excels at reducing motion transfer and providing exceptional support. What sets it apart from other models is the addition of 10 percent more coils, further enhancing its firmness and support.

Designed with the needs of individuals suffering from back, neck, and joint pain in mind, the Zinus Performance Plus mattress offers targeted relief and alignment. While the foam layer on top may not be the main attraction, its purpose is to complement the overall firmness and support of the mattress.

One of the notable advantages of this mattress is its suitability for heavier individuals. The extra firmness provides optimal support, ensuring that even larger body types receive the necessary comfort and stability. Additionally, the reinforced edges maintain their firmness over time, making it ideal for both sleeping and using as a surrogate couch without worrying about sagging or loss of support.

Despite the typically higher cost associated with pocketed coil mattresses, the Zinus Performance Plus offers exceptional value for its firmness level. Customers have praised its affordability and the consistent quality provided by the company. With this mattress, you can expect long-lasting durability and a reliable sleep surface that maintains its sturdy construction for years to come.

Choose the Zinus Performance Plus mattress for unrivaled firmness, superior support, and targeted pain relief. Whether you prefer to sleep on your back, side, or stomach, this mattress caters to various sleep styles while offering exceptional value and quality.

Plank Mattress by Brooklyn Bedding

Brooklyn Bedding is renowned for its commitment to crafting exceptional beds, and their Plank mattress stands as a testament to their expertise in providing firmness without compromising on comfort. This mattress utilizes multiple layers of dense foam to deliver a truly firm sleep surface. However, for those concerned about a mattress being too firm, the Plank offers a 2-sided design with dual firmness options. One side features an industry-standard “firm” feel, while flipping it over reveals an “extra firm” surface for those seeking even greater firmness.

The incorporation of patented foam in the inner layers plays a crucial role in achieving the desired firmness while effectively reducing heat retention. These layers, combined with a thick knit top cover, create a gentle touch that offers comfortable cushioning, even for individuals desiring a particularly firm mattress. It’s worth noting that both sides of the mattress feature durable border edges, ensuring that you remain supported and secure, without the risk of rolling off or experiencing sagging.

The Plank mattress employs advanced technology to provide targeted support to the center of your body, where it’s needed most. This feature, combined with its exceptional firmness, effectively minimizes motion transfer, making it an ideal choice for bed-sharing partners or individuals who tend to be restless during sleep.

Whether you prefer to sleep on your back, side, or stomach, the Brooklyn Bedding Plank mattress offers the necessary support and firmness to accommodate various sleep styles and positions. Furthermore, its robust construction makes it suitable for a wide range of body types, ensuring reliable support and comfort throughout the night.

Further reading: Check our full Plank mattress review for more details on this extra firm mattress.

Live and Sleep Resort Elite 10 Inch

The Live and Sleep Resort Elite mattress strikes the ideal balance between support and comfort, offering a medium-firm feel that provides excellent support without feeling overly rigid. Crafted with multiple foam layers, including air flow memory foam, gel-infused foam, and a high-density support base, this mattress ensures optimal support and pressure relief. While it excels in motion isolation, it may not provide the firm support some sleepers require. However, side sleepers may find that the slightly softer feel allows them to enjoy the benefits of a firmer mattress.

The airflow and cooling properties of the foam layers contribute to temperature regulation, helping to prevent overheating during sleep. However, it’s important to note that being a foam mattress rather than a spring one, individuals who tend to sleep hot may still experience some temperature-related issues.

While the foam used in the Live and Sleep Resort Elite is soft, it’s important to keep in mind that it may not retain its initial softness over an extended period. This mattress doesn’t feature high-grade, traditional memory foam, so those seeking that specific feel may need to explore other options. The durability and softness retention of the mattress may vary depending on factors such as body weight and the level of heat experienced during sleep.

When comparing the Live and Sleep Resort Elite to previous mattresses, it offers a unique blend of support, comfort, and motion isolation. While it may not provide the firm support some sleepers desire, its medium-firm feel appeals to a wide range of individuals, particularly side sleepers who prefer a slightly softer mattress. The cooling properties of the foam layers help maintain a comfortable temperature, although it’s important to consider personal preferences and tendencies towards sleeping hot. Ultimately, the Live and Sleep Resort Elite offers a compelling option for those seeking a balanced and comfortable sleep experience.

Purple Bed

Introducing the Purple Mattress, a nontraditional and innovative sleep solution crafted by the renowned company, Purple. Unlike traditional memory foam mattresses, the Purple Mattress features a unique material called Hyper-Elastic Polymer™. Made from non-toxic and food-grade materials, this proprietary material offers the comfort of memory foam without the associated drawbacks. With its VOC and odor-free composition, you can enjoy a refreshing and health-conscious sleep environment. Notably, Purple assures customers that their mattress will maintain its shape without sagging or indenting over time, ensuring long-lasting support.

The extra firmness of the Purple Mattress caters particularly well to back and stomach sleepers, providing the necessary support for proper spinal alignment. However, side sleepers may find the lack of contouring disappointing, as the mattress does not offer significant give for enhanced pressure relief. On the positive side, the Purple Mattress excels in temperature regulation, avoiding the common heating issues often associated with memory foam mattresses.

When comparing the Purple Mattress to more traditional options, its unique composition sets it apart. The use of Hyper-Elastic Polymer™ creates a mattress that is both comfortable and durable, addressing concerns related to sagging and indentation. While it may not provide the same level of contouring preferred by side sleepers, its extra firmness caters well to back and stomach sleepers. Additionally, its ability to regulate temperature adds to the overall sleep experience. For those seeking an unconventional yet high-quality mattress, the Purple Mattress offers a compelling choice.

Further reading: If you’d like more information on the Purple, we have conducted a full in-depth review of this product which can be found here.

Loom & Leaf by Saatva

Introducing the Loom and Leaf mattress, a top-of-the-line offering from a renowned brand. This mattress is available in two firmness options: Relaxed-Firm and Firm, both designed to provide exceptional firm support. Crafted with a focus on gel-infused foam, the Loom and Leaf mattress stands out for its ability to deliver a cool and balanced sleep experience. The innovative Spinal Zone Gel technology ensures optimal spine and joint support while effectively minimizing motion transfer from restless bedmates. Despite its relatively thin foam layers, the mattress maintains a true firm feel, offering a solid and supportive surface.

While the foam layers are not thick, they are specifically engineered to address heat reduction, making the mattress suitable for individuals sensitive to temperature. Additionally, the Loom and Leaf mattress ensures consistent support throughout, as there is no foam encasement around the edge that could lead to sagging or unevenness.

The foam layers work in harmony to deliver an evenly firm feel, promoting restful nights and pain-free days. Although this level of performance comes at a price, many customers express satisfaction even after transitioning from higher-priced mattresses. The Loom and Leaf strikes the perfect balance of firmness without crossing into overly “hard” territory.

With a generous 15-year warranty, a risk-free 180-night trial, and the convenience of free shipping and setup, the Loom and Leaf mattress stands as one of the best investments for those seeking a top-quality firm mattress. Experience premium firmness, exceptional cooling, and unmatched support with the Loom and Leaf mattress.

Further reading: Check our detailed Loom & Leaf review for more info on the Firm option.

Conclusion

Choosing among these mattresses was a challenging task due to their variations, but the Zinus 12 Inch Performance Plus Extra Firm hybrid spring and foam mattress emerges as the clear winner.

This mattress strikes the ideal balance between firmness and comfort. The pocketed springs work smoothly to minimize motion transfer while providing crucial support to key pressure points. The additional foam layers contribute to a comfortable feel without causing overheating, thanks to the cooling features integrated into the design. Furthermore, the reinforced sides prevent the edges from sagging, ensuring a consistently restful experience.

However, it’s important to remember that while the Zinus model is the top choice for firm mattresses in our list, it doesn’t guarantee a perfect fit or comfort for everyone. It is likely well-suited for sleepers seeking a firmer sleeping surface, but thorough testing is necessary to ensure suitability. Always make sure to thoroughly read and understand trial periods and return policies to make an informed decision.