Top 10 Crib Mattresses Reviewed in 2024

Our editors independently researched the best products online to produce this list. We may receive commission on purchases made from the links below but this will never affect our product choices. Click here to read our disclosure.

---

Choosing the best crib mattress is essential for providing your baby with a safe and comfortable sleeping environment. A quality crib mattress not only supports healthy sleep development but also ensures peace of mind for parents. In 2024, there are numerous options available, including foam, innerspring, and organic mattresses, each designed with specific features to cater to your child’s needs. This guide will help you navigate the top choices, highlighting key factors such as firmness, materials, safety certifications, and durability.

In this guide, we’ll explore the best crib mattresses of 2024, focusing on crucial aspects like firmness levels, weight, and ease of maintenance. A firm mattress is recommended for infants to reduce the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) and promote safe sleep practices. We’ll also discuss important features such as waterproof covers, breathability, and hypoallergenic materials to ensure a healthy sleep environment. By comparing these top-rated crib mattresses, you can find the perfect fit that meets both safety standards and your child’s comfort needs, creating a nurturing sleep space that supports their growth and development.

How We Compared The Mattresses

We compared the best crib mattresses by evaluating key factors. Firstly, we considered the type of mattress, whether it was foam or innerspring, to assess the level of support and comfort it provided. This helped us understand the specific qualities and benefits of each type. We also examined the firmness levels of the mattresses, recognizing the importance of selecting a firm surface to support proper bone development and minimize risks such as suffocation or Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS).

In addition to support and firmness, we carefully examined the waterproof features of the crib mattresses. We understood the significance of a mattress that is resistant to spills and accidents, as well as being easy to clean. This included assessing the presence of a waterproof cover or a removable, machine-washable surface. By considering the waterproof capabilities, we aimed to provide parents with options that facilitate maintenance and hygiene.

Moreover, we prioritized safety standards during our evaluation. We thoroughly researched and compared the safety certifications and compliance of each crib mattress. This ensured that they met the necessary requirements for crib use, including proper fit and the absence of harmful chemicals. Our goal was to provide parents with concise and reliable information, allowing them to make an informed decision and select a crib mattress that prioritizes their baby’s comfort, support, and overall well-being.

How To Choose The Best Crib Mattress

Choosing the best crib mattress for your baby is essential for their safety, comfort, and healthy development. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to decide, but key factors like size, fit, firmness, material, and breathability can help guide your choice. A snug-fitting mattress without gaps is crucial to prevent entrapment, while a firm mattress is recommended to support your baby’s body and reduce the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). Mattresses made from non-toxic materials such as organic cotton or natural latex can minimize exposure to harmful chemicals, and good airflow helps keep your baby cool during sleep.

In addition to these essential factors, it’s also important to consider features like waterproofing for easy cleaning, certifications from safety organizations, and durability to ensure the mattress lasts throughout your baby’s early years. Some mattresses even offer dual-sided designs, with one side firm for infants and the other softer for toddlers, providing long-term value. Finally, considering brand reputation and customer reviews can help you make an informed decision by learning from other parents’ experiences with the mattress’s comfort, durability, and ease of maintenance.

By prioritizing safety, comfort, and quality materials, and taking into account factors like certifications, ease of cleaning, and customer feedback, you can find a crib mattress that not only meets your baby’s needs but also provides peace of mind for you as a parent.

The Best Crib Mattresses In Detail

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core

When it comes to crib mattresses, Sealy is a name that stands out for its commitment to excellence. In fact, their mattresses and pads have been recognized as America’s Best for Baby, earning the prestigious Women’s Choice Award in both 2013 and 2014. Within their portfolio, the Soybean Foam Core model is an award-winning addition that sets a new standard for crib mattresses.

While it may not have the double-sided feature found in some other toddler mattress options, the Sealy Soybean Foam Core offers an unbeatable combination of firmness and comfort for your little one. Its high-density core, enhanced with cotton cushioning, provides a supportive and comfortable sleeping surface that promotes healthy sleep for your baby.

Safety and cleanliness are top priorities with the Sealy Soybean Foam Core Crib Mattress. The pearl embossed cover is not only 100% waterproof but also stain-resistant, ensuring that accidents and spills can be easily managed. The hypoallergenic foam core, CertiPUR-US® certified and made with soybean oils, offers a healthier alternative to petroleum-based alternatives. You can rest easy knowing that your baby is sleeping on a mattress free from harmful chemicals.

Designed with safety in mind, the Sealy Soybean Foam Core features a square cornered design that ensures a secure fit in the crib. It meets ASTM standards for crib mattresses and holds the prestigious GREENGUARD Gold certification, indicating low chemical emissions and promoting a healthier indoor environment.

In summary, the Sealy Soybean Foam Core Crib Mattress is unmatched in terms of quality, safety, and comfort for your baby. Its recognition as America’s Best for Baby speaks volumes about its excellence. With its waterproof and stain-resistant cover, hypoallergenic foam core, and adherence to stringent safety standards, this mattress provides peace of mind for parents. When it comes to choosing a crib mattress, the Sealy Soybean Foam Core is the ultimate choice.

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer

When it comes to crib mattresses, the 5″ thick Moonlight Slumber we have in our top 10 reviews stands out as one of the best. This CertiPUR-US® certified model sets a high standard for quality and safety, ensuring a peaceful sleep environment for your little one. It is free from vinyl, polyethylene, PVC, phthalates, and lead, prioritizing the well-being of your baby.

One of the standout features of the Little Dreamer crib mattress is its double-sided design, making it a long-lasting investment. The extra firm infant side provides the necessary support for newborns and young babies, while the lesser firm toddler side offers a comfortable transition as your child grows. This dual functionality ensures that this mattress will accompany your child well into their toddler years.

Safety is paramount with this crib mattress. The dropped side-stitched seams, hypoallergenic composition, and waterproof surface all contribute to a secure and hygienic sleep environment. Weighing a mere 10.5 lbs, it is lightweight and easy to handle. Verified owners of this baby mattress have praised the square and cornered edges, which provide an excellent snug fit in the crib, eliminating any concerns about unsafe gaps.

While this may not be the most budget-friendly crib mattress option, the quality and safety it offers make it worth the investment. When it comes to your baby’s sleep environment, compromising on quality is not an option. With this mattress, you truly get what you pay for: exceptional quality, safety, and longevity.

In conclusion, the double-sided crib mattress we have reviewed is a top-rated choice for quality-conscious parents. Its CertiPUR-US® certification, double-sided functionality, and attention to safety details make it a standout option. The square and cornered edges ensure a snug fit, while the hypoallergenic and waterproof features provide peace of mind. Choose this crib mattress for the best in quality, safety, and long-term value for your baby.

Colgate Eco Classica III

With over half a century of expertise in the baby bed mattress industry, the Atlanta-based team behind the Eco Classica III has established themselves as specialists. It’s no surprise that their product has earned a spot in our top 10 comparisons. This GREENGUARD certified double-sided mattress showcases their commitment to quality and safety.

The Eco Classica III features dual firmness, catering to both infants and toddlers. One side offers very firm support, ideal for newborns and young babies, while the other side provides a softer yet still firm comfort layer for growing toddlers. The CertiPUR-US® certified core is plant-based, ensuring healthier materials by replacing petroleum-based oils with plant oils. This not only reduces harmful air emissions but also eliminates any unpleasant off-gassing odors.

Weighing a lightweight 9.3 lbs, the Eco Classica III is wrapped in a certified organic cotton cover with a waterproof backing. This thoughtful design places healthy cloth closest to the baby’s skin while the waterproof backing prevents any seepage. It is an all-around healthy choice, providing parents with the peace of mind of a natural sleep environment for their child.

When comparing the Eco Classica III to the previously mentioned crib mattresses, it stands out for its orthopedic style and GREENGUARD certification. While all three mattresses prioritize quality and safety, the Eco Classica III’s plant-based core and organic cotton cover elevate its eco-friendly and natural attributes. Its dual firmness options and lightweight design are also noteworthy features. Parents seeking a trusted choice with an emphasis on a natural sleep environment will find the Eco Classica III to be an exceptional option.

Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers

Continuing the trend of providing top-quality crib mattresses, Beautyrest proves once again why they are a prominent American contender in the market. The Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers is a prime example of their commitment to excellence.

This double-sided innerspring crib mattress features 231 pocketed coil springs, ensuring even support for your baby or toddler. One side offers the ideal firmness for newborns, providing a safe and supportive sleep surface. On the flip side, a layer of convoluted foam accommodates the needs of growing toddlers, offering a softer yet still comfortable feel.

The Simmons Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers is both GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US® certified, guaranteeing a healthier indoor environment for your little one. It is hypoallergenic, non-toxic, and water-resistant, making it a safe and hygienic choice. The natural cotton fire protection wrap adds an extra layer of safety without the use of harmful chemicals. With this crib mattress, you can have peace of mind knowing that your baby is sleeping on a product that prioritizes their well-being.

In terms of value, the Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers offers everything you could ask for at a great price. It combines quality, versatility, and safety features that ensure a restful and secure sleep environment for your baby.

When comparing the Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers to the previously discussed crib mattresses, it stands out for its innerspring design and the specific support it provides through pocketed coil springs. Its double-sided functionality, GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US® certifications, and water-resistant properties further contribute to its appeal. Beautyrest continues to deliver exceptional quality, comfort, and value with the Sleepy Whispers crib mattress.

In conclusion, the Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers is a standout choice for parents seeking a high-quality and versatile crib mattress. Its double-sided design, innerspring support, and thoughtful safety features make it a reliable option for both newborns and growing toddlers. With its certifications and hygienic properties, it ensures a healthier sleep environment. Choose the Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers for a crib mattress that combines quality, comfort, and affordability in one exceptional package.

Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic

Naturepedic, one of the leading manufacturers in the organic mattress field, continues to deliver top-quality products. As a GOTS certified manufacturer that meets rigorous GREENGUARD certification standards, they prioritize eliminating chemical emissions and providing a truly organic sleep experience.

The Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic Seamless 150 baby crib and toddler bed mattress has garnered numerous awards for its exceptional ability to create a natural, healthy, and comfortable sleep environment. With a double-sided design, it offers a firm infant side for optimal support and a flippable softer side for older children, accommodating their changing needs as they grow.

This mattress features seamless waterproof edges, 150 coils for superior support, and edge support for added stability. It boasts 100% organic cotton throughout, promoting a truly organic sleep surface. The firm yet easy-to-clean non-toxic waterproof surface ensures a hygienic and safe sleep environment for your baby.

While the Naturepedic may not be the most budget-friendly option compared to foam or innerspring alternatives, it sets the standard for organic mattresses. Its commitment to organic excellence, seamless design, and the use of high-quality materials make it an outstanding choice for health-conscious parents.

When comparing the Naturepedic to the Sealy Soybean crib mattress, both mattresses emphasize organic materials and certifications. However, the Naturepedic mattress stands out for its GOTS certification, seamless design, and the use of 100% organic cotton throughout. The double-sided functionality and superior coil support are additional features that set it apart. If you are seeking the highest standard of organic excellence, the Naturepedic is the ideal choice.

In conclusion, the Naturepedic crib mattress is an exceptional crib mattress that prioritizes organic excellence and uncompromised comfort. With its seamless design, superior coil support, and use of 100% organic cotton, it provides a natural and healthy sleep environment for your baby. While it may come at a higher price point, its GOTS certification and numerous awards reflect its status as a top-quality organic option. Choose the Naturepedic mattress for unparalleled organic excellence in a crib mattress.

Newton Wovenaire

The Newton Wovenaire Baby Crib Mattress is a standout choice that has earned both GREENGUARD certification and prestigious awards like the JPMA innovation award. Its unique construction, featuring a 3-D spacer cover and Wovenaire material, ensures a firm yet comfortable surface, catering to the needs of both infants and toddlers.

One of the notable features of the Newton Wovenaire is its 90% air polymer material, which contributes to its lightweight design. This material not only reduces the presence of harmful chemicals commonly found in foam crib mattresses but also enhances breathability. With its lower suffocation risk and improved airflow, this mattress provides a safer and more comfortable sleep environment for your baby. Additionally, the Wovenaire material is 100% washable, allowing you to easily maintain a clean and hygienic mattress. Simply remove the cover and toss it in the washing machine for a thorough cleaning. After air drying, you’ll have a fresh-smelling mattress ready for use again.

The Newton Wovenaire crib mattress combines breathability, comfort, support, lightweight design, and washability, making it one of the best options available for parents. Its innovative features ensure a safe and healthy sleep environment for your baby, while the ease of maintenance adds to its practicality.

When comparing the Newton Wovenaire to the previously discussed crib mattresses, it stands out for its unique 3-D spacer cover and the use of Wovenaire material. The emphasis on breathability, lightweight design, and washability further differentiate it. The Newton Wovenaire offers a blend of innovation, safety, and convenience that sets it apart in the competitive crib mattress market.

In conclusion, the Newton Wovenaire Baby Crib Mattress is a top-tier choice that delivers exceptional breathability, innovation, and comfort. With its GREENGUARD certification, award-winning design, and use of Wovenaire material, it surpasses industry standards. The lightweight design, washable cover, and overall performance make it a valuable investment for parents seeking a high-quality crib mattress. Choose the Newton Wovenaire for a breathable, comfortable, and supportive sleep surface that offers excellent value for your money.

Serta Tranquility Eco Firm

The Serta Tranquility is a traditional innerspring mattress designed for cribs or toddler beds. With an inner composition of 120 heavy-duty coils, it offers exceptional support and durability. While it may not be as lightweight as some foam options, the Serta Tranquility boasts numerous benefits that make it a worthy choice.

One of the standout features of the Serta Tranquility is its ortho-insulated layer, providing both comfort and durability. It ensures a supportive sleep surface for your baby, promoting healthy spinal alignment and overall well-being. Furthermore, this mattress has received the GREENGUARD Gold certification and has passed CPSIA testing, ensuring it is free from phthalates, lead, and toxic fire retardants. With the Serta Tranquility, you can have peace of mind knowing that your baby is sleeping on a safe and healthy mattress.

While primarily designed for babies, the Serta Tranquility also offers benefits for parents. Although sleeping on the mattress may not be feasible due to its dimensions, its durability allows for enjoyable playtime with your baby while sitting on the mattress. The toddler side features a blended cotton layer, ensuring optimal comfort throughout the night. With its square corners, the mattress fits snugly in the crib, eliminating any concerns about unsafe gaps. It is important to note that the Serta Tranquility is a firm crib mattress, so this aspect should be considered when making your shortlist.

With its exceptional durability, the Serta Tranquility is built to last throughout your baby’s infancy and beyond. It is unlikely to require replacement until it is outgrown, making it a wise investment.

In summary, the Serta Tranquility offers traditional comfort and durability for your baby’s sleep needs. Its heavy-duty coil construction, ortho-insulated layer, and safety certifications ensure a supportive and healthy sleep environment. The added benefits for parents and the mattress’s long-lasting nature further contribute to its appeal. Choose the Serta Tranquility for a reliable and durable crib mattress that will provide comfort and support for years to come.

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams

When it comes to safe baby products, Safety 1st is a renowned brand that consistently delivers. The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams mattress lives up to this reputation, providing a reliable and secure sleep surface for your little one. In fact, it has been recognized with the 2017 Women’s Choice Award as America’s Most Recommended Brand for Crib & Toddler Mattress.

This mattress for cribs and toddler beds is not only hypoallergenic but also holds the esteemed GREENGUARD Gold certification. The thermos-bonded core, constructed with high-density foam and a vinyl cover, ensures exceptional durability. Despite its sturdiness, the high-density foam does not compromise on comfort, creating a cozy sleeping environment for your infant. The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams mattress fits snugly in the crib and offers excellent edge support, adding an extra layer of safety and peace of mind. Weighing in at a mere eight pounds, it is lightweight and allows for easy sheet changes even in the middle of the night.

The hypoallergenic and odor-resistant mattress cover is ideal for babies with sensitivities to allergens. While the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams mattress does not have specific temperature regulation features, it does not retain excessive heat, ensuring a comfortable sleeping experience without causing sweating or overheating. The vinyl cover is waterproof and easy to clean, minimizing the time spent on cleaning your child’s mess and allowing you to focus on enjoying your sleep.

Safety is paramount with the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams mattress, as it is free from phthalates and lead. With its GREENGUARD Gold Certification, this mattress meets rigorous safety standards for low emissions. In our opinion, it stands as a top contender for the best crib mattress this year.

In summary, the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams mattress combines trusted safety features with comfort for your baby. Its hypoallergenic construction, GREENGUARD Gold certification, and durable design ensure a secure and healthy sleep environment. The lightweight nature, excellent edge support, and easy-to-clean features further enhance its appeal. Choose the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams mattress for a reliable and comfortable crib mattress that prioritizes your baby’s safety and well-being.

Graco Premium Foam

The Graco Premium Foam mattress is an exceptional choice if you’re seeking a solution to reduce your child’s heat buildup during sleep. Not only is this mattress of high quality, but it is also designed with breathability in mind, allowing for easy airflow while your baby slumbers.

Featuring a waterproof lining, the Graco Premium Foam mattress ensures a dry sleeping surface even if your child sweats during the night. To prioritize hygiene and safety, Graco has incorporated antimicrobial and anti-static features into the mattress. While not 100% organic, it is crafted using safe materials to provide peace of mind to parents.

In addition to its impressive features, the Graco Premium Foam mattress is lightweight, weighing just seven pounds. It offers a reasonable price point compared to other products in our reviews, making it an accessible choice. Designed to fit any full-size crib or toddler bed, it offers versatility and convenience.

When it comes to safety, the Graco Premium Foam mattress is free from lead and phthalates, ensuring a secure environment for your child. What sets it apart is the inclusion of a six-year limited manufacturer’s warranty, a testament to its durability and quality. Unlike cheaper alternatives, the Graco Premium Foam mattress is not excessively bouncy or noisy, providing a peaceful sleeping experience for your baby. Moreover, it meets flammability standards set by the Federal Government, further enhancing its safety features.

In summary, the Graco Premium Foam mattress combines breathable comfort and safety for your baby’s sleep needs. Its emphasis on airflow, waterproof properties, and antimicrobial features contribute to a hygienic and comfortable sleeping environment. The lightweight design, reasonable price, and manufacturer’s warranty add to its appeal. Choose the Graco Premium Foam mattress for a reliable and comfortable option that prioritizes your baby’s well-being.

Millard Crib and Toddler

The Millard crib and toddler mattress is designed to provide the perfect balance of firmness and comfort, ensuring a restful sleep for your infant or toddler.

With its CertiPUR certification, you can rest assured that the foam used in this mattress is safe and free from harmful chemicals. It is non-toxic and completely organic, offering a healthy sleeping environment for your little one. The foam is also manufactured without the use of TCEP, TDCPP, or PBDE flame retardants, minimizing exposure to potentially harmful byproducts. The Millard mattress is built with your child’s safety in mind.

Equipped with a protective cover, the Millard mattress safeguards against spills and provides protection against dust mites, allergens, mold, and mildew. This added layer of defense ensures a clean and hygienic sleep surface for your baby.

One of the standout features of the Millard mattress is its ability to fit perfectly within a standard crib. It eliminates any gaps or spaces along the edges, providing a snug and secure fit. The 90-degree edges effortlessly fill in the crib corners, ensuring your child is safe from unwanted gaps within the crib structure.

Manufactured and designed in the USA, the Millard crib and toddler mattress meets high-quality standards. It comes with a 30-day warranty, giving you added peace of mind with your purchase. With its focus on safety, comfort, and reasonable pricing, the Millard mattress is an excellent choice for parents.

In summary, the Millard crib and toddler mattress delivers optimal comfort and health benefits for your little one. Its CertiPUR certification, non-toxic and organic composition, and protective cover ensure a safe and hygienic sleeping environment. The precise fit within a standard crib and the added warranty further enhance its appeal. Choose the Millard mattress for a safe, comfortable, and reasonably priced option that prioritizes your child’s well-being.

Conclusion

Our recent baby mattress reviews have led us to a difficult decision. Instead of choosing a single best crib mattress, we present our top two favorites.

The Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer, a traditional polyurethane foam mattress, and the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core, an organic option, both offer comfort, durability, and value. While the Sealy Soybean stands out for its natural, non-toxic composition and health benefits, the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer excels in orthopedic support and comfort.

Ultimately, the choice depends on your preferences and needs. We hope our crib mattress reviews aid you in selecting the best option for your baby.