Plank Mattress Review: Ultra-Firm or Ultra-Waste?

We may receive a commission on purchases made from the links below, but this will never affect our opinions or product choices. Click here to read our disclosure.


In today’s fast-paced world, getting a good night’s sleep is more important than ever. A quality mattress can make all the difference in ensuring restful and rejuvenating sleep. Brooklyn Bedding, a renowned mattress company in the United States, has been committed to providing comfortable and supportive mattresses to cater to different types of sleepers. One of their most popular and unique offerings is the Plank Mattress, an all-foam, flippable mattress designed for those who prefer a firmer sleep surface. In this detailed and in-depth review, I will share my personal experience with the Plank Mattress and discuss its various features, pros, and cons to help you make an informed decision.

Feature Description
Type All-foam, flippable mattress
Firmness Levels Medium-firm (6.5) and ultra-firm
Construction 4 layers of high-density foams, including a latex alternative foam
Cover Breathable, quilted cover
Motion Isolation Excellent motion isolation due to all-foam construction
Edge Support Solid edge support for an all-foam mattress
Temperature Regulation Minimal heat retention with breathable cover and latex alternative foam
Pressure Relief Provides targeted pressure relief for back and stomach sleepers
Sleep Positions Best suited for back and stomach sleepers; may not be ideal for side sleepers
Sleep Trial 120-night sleep trial
Warranty 10-year warranty
Shipping Free shipping within the contiguous United States; additional fees for Alaska, Hawaii, and Canada
Price Range Varies depending on the mattress size; check the website for current prices
Suitable For Back and stomach sleepers, those who prefer firmer sleep surfaces, and individuals with back pain

Shop The Plank Mattress

Construction and Materials

The Plank Mattress by Brooklyn Bedding features a minimalist approach with a flippable design, offering two distinct firmness levels: firm and ultra-firm. The firm side has a 6.5 (medium-firm) firmness rating, while the ultra-firm side provides an ultra-firm sleep experience. The mattress consists of four distinct layers of high-density foams, including a layer of latex-like poly foam and a layer of high-density base foam.

  • Firm Side: On the firm side, you’ll find an inch of comfort foam that provides a touch of softness, followed by a layer of latex alternative foam, which offers moderate bounce and responsiveness. This combination provides a firm surface with a bit of cushioning for added comfort.
  • Ultra-Firm Side: The ultra-firm side features an additional layer of high-density poly foam, providing an extra-firm sleep surface with minimal sinkage and limited contouring. This side is perfect for those who prefer a flat surface with very little cushioning.

Firmness and Feel

Plank mattress

The flippable design of the Plank Mattress is a standout feature, offering two firmness options in one mattress. The firm side is rated at a 6.5 (medium-firm) on the firmness scale, providing a good balance of comfort and support for a variety of sleepers, including back and stomach sleepers. The ultra-firm side, on the other hand, is rated as one of the firmest mattresses available and is an ideal choice for those who prefer a very firm sleep surface with minimal sinkage.

I personally found the firm side to be quite comfortable, providing just the right amount of support without causing any pain or discomfort. The ultra-firm side was a bit too firm for my liking, but it’s perfect for those who prefer an extra-firm sleeping surface. I also appreciated the mattress’s ability to maintain a consistent temperature, thanks to the high-density foams used in its construction.

Motion Isolation and Edge Support

The Plank Mattress excels in motion isolation, ensuring that movements on one side of the bed don’t disturb the other side. This feature is particularly beneficial for couples, especially if one partner is a light sleeper or tends to toss and turn throughout the night. The all-foam construction of the mattress effectively minimizes motion transfer, providing a peaceful and undisturbed sleep.

When it comes to edge support, the Plank Mattress offers a solid and strong edge, which is quite impressive for an all-foam bed. The high-density base foam provides a stable foundation, ensuring that the mattress maintains its shape and support even when sitting or sleeping near the edge. This level of edge support is a welcome feature, as it allows for better utilization of the entire mattress surface.

Pressure Relief and Support

The Plank Mattress offers a range of firmness options, catering to different sleepers with varying preferences and needs. The firm side provides a good balance of support and pressure relief, ensuring that your body weight is distributed evenly across the mattress. This helps in alleviating pressure points, particularly in areas such as the shoulders, hips, and lower back. The ultra-firm side, on the other hand, offers minimal sinkage and contouring, making it suitable for those who prefer a very firm sleep surface with limited cushioning.

For stomach sleepers, the Plank Mattress is an excellent choice as it provides adequate support for the torso and helps maintain proper spinal alignment. This is especially true for the ultra-firm side, which offers a flat and supportive surface, minimizing the risk of developing pain in the lower back or hips. Similarly, back sleepers can benefit from both the firm and ultra-firm sides, depending on their individual preferences and body weight.

Side sleepers, however, may find the Plank Mattress a bit too firm for their liking, particularly those with a lighter body weight. The mattress may not provide enough cushioning for the shoulders and hips, which can result in discomfort and pressure points. For these individuals, a softer mattress or hybrid mattress with better pressure point relief may be a more suitable option.

Temperature Regulation

The Plank Mattress performs relatively well when it comes to temperature regulation, thanks to the combination of high-density foams and the latex alternative foam layer. These materials work together to minimize heat retention and maintain a comfortable sleep temperature throughout the night. While memory foam mattresses are known for trapping body heat, the Plank Mattress’s choice of materials and construction helps to mitigate this issue.

That said, if you are a hot sleeper or live in a warmer climate, you may still find the Plank Mattress to be slightly warmer than your liking. In such cases, you might want to consider the Plank Firm Luxe, a hybrid model that features a layer of phase-change material for improved temperature regulation. The hybrid design, which combines foam layers with an innerspring core, also allows for better airflow and breathability, providing a cooler sleep experience.

Price, Warranty, and Trial Period

The Plank Mattress by Brooklyn Bedding is competitively priced, offering an affordable option for those seeking a high-quality, all-foam mattress with a flippable design. The mattress is available in a variety of sizes, catering to different preferences and budget constraints. While sales and discounts may be offered from time to time, the current prices are as follows:

  • Twin: $699
  • Twin XL: $749
  • Full: $849
  • Queen: $999
  • King: $1,249
  • California King: $1,249

It’s worth noting that the Plank Firm Luxe, the hybrid version of the mattress, comes at an additional cost. However, considering the added benefits of temperature regulation and improved support for heavier sleepers, the investment may be worthwhile for some individuals.

Brooklyn Bedding offers a 120-night sleep trial, allowing you to test the Plank Mattress in the comfort of your own home. If you decide the mattress isn’t the right fit for you, the company will work with you to arrange a return and issue a full refund. It’s important to note that the sleep trial has a mandatory 30-day break-in period, which means you must try the mattress for at least 30 nights before initiating a return.

The Plank Mattress comes with a 10-year warranty, which is the industry standard for mattresses. This warranty covers defects in materials and workmanship, including body impressions greater than 1 inch, and provides peace of mind for your investment.

Shipping and Additional Services

Plank mattress

Brooklyn Bedding offers free shipping within the contiguous United States, with additional shipping fees applicable for deliveries to Alaska, Hawaii, and Canada. The mattress is shipped as a bed-in-a-box, which means it is compressed, rolled, and packaged in a compact box for easy transportation and setup. Once the mattress arrives, simply unbox it, place it on your bed frame, and allow it to decompress and expand to its full size.

Apart from the standard shipping option, Brooklyn Bedding also offers White Glove Delivery and Old Mattress Removal services at an additional charge. These services can be helpful for those who require assistance with setting up their new mattress or disposing of their old one.

Who Is the Plank Mattress Best For?

The Plank Mattress is an excellent choice for a variety of sleepers, particularly those who prefer a firmer sleep surface. The flippable design offers two firmness options, catering to different preferences and sleep positions.

  • Stomach sleepers: The Plank Mattress provides the necessary support for stomach sleepers, ensuring proper spinal alignment and reducing the risk of developing lower back or hip pain.
  • Back sleepers: Both the firm and ultra-firm sides of the mattress offer adequate support for back sleepers, depending on their body weight and individual preferences.
  • Heavy people: The Plank Mattress’s high-density foams and extra-firm side make it a suitable option for heavier individuals who require a more supportive sleep surface.
  • People who prefer a firm mattress: With its dual-sided firmness options, the Plank Mattress is an ideal choice for those who enjoy a firmer sleep surface.

Who Is the Plank Mattress Not Ideal For?

The Plank Mattress may not be the best choice for everyone. Here are some sleepers who might not find it suitable:

  • Lightweight side sleepers: The mattress may be too firm for lightweight side sleepers, who typically require more cushioning for pressure point relief.
  • Hot sleepers: Although the Plank Mattress offers decent temperature regulation, hot sleepers may still find it slightly warmer than they prefer. In such cases, the Plank Firm Luxe, a hybrid model with improved temperature regulation, may be a better option.

Shop The Plank Mattress

Plank Mattress Alternatives

Here are a few alternatives to consider and compare against the Plank Mattress.

Plank Mattress vs Amersleep AS1

Amerisleep as1

The Amerisleep AS1 and Plank Mattress are both all-foam mattresses that cater to sleepers who prefer a firmer sleep surface. The Amerisleep AS1 is designed as a firm mattress with a 2-inch layer of Bio-Pur memory foam, which offers pressure relief and temperature regulation. The Plank Mattress, on the other hand, offers dual-sided firmness options, catering to a broader range of firmness preferences and sleeping positions.

While both mattresses provide excellent motion isolation, the Plank Mattress has a slight edge when it comes to edge support, thanks to its high-density base foam. Ultimately, the choice between the Amerisleep AS1 and the Plank Mattress will come down to your personal comfort preferences and desired firmness level.

Plank Mattress vs Serta Perfect Sleeper

Serta perfect sleeper

The Serta Perfect Sleeper and Plank Mattress cater to different sleep preferences with their distinct constructions. The Serta Perfect Sleeper is a line of innerspring and hybrid mattresses, while the Plank Mattress is a flippable all-foam mattress with dual-sided firmness options.

The Serta Perfect Sleeper series offers various firmness levels and combinations of memory foam, gel-infused foam, and innerspring coils, providing tailored support and pressure relief for different sleep positions. The Plank Mattress focuses on firmness, with a medium-firm side and an ultra-firm side, making it suitable for back and stomach sleepers, as well as those who prefer a firmer sleep surface.

Both mattresses provide good motion isolation, but the Plank Mattress might perform better due to its all-foam construction. Edge support, on the other hand, could be more robust in the Serta Perfect Sleeper, especially in the hybrid models. When choosing between the Serta Perfect Sleeper and the Plank Mattress, consider your sleep position, desired firmness level, and whether you prefer an innerspring, hybrid, or all-foam construction.

Plank Mattress vs Helix Twilight

Helix twilight

When comparing the Plank Mattress to the Helix Twilight, it is evident that both cater to sleepers who prefer firmer mattresses, but they have some differences in construction and materials that set them apart.

The Plank Mattress is a flippable all-foam mattress with dual-sided firmness options, offering a medium-firm side and an ultra-firm side. This design allows sleepers to choose between two firmness levels, catering to back and stomach sleepers, as well as those who prefer a firmer sleep surface.

The Helix Twilight, on the other hand, is a hybrid mattress with a single firmness level, rated as firm on the firmness scale. It combines memory foam and individually wrapped coils, providing a balance between contouring and support. The Helix Twilight is particularly suitable for back and stomach sleepers, as well as heavier individuals who require additional support from a mattress.

In terms of motion isolation, both mattresses perform well, but the all-foam construction of the Plank Mattress might offer slightly better motion isolation than the Helix Twilight’s hybrid design. Conversely, the hybrid construction of the Helix Twilight typically provides better edge support and temperature regulation compared to the Plank Mattress.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Plank Mattress by Brooklyn Bedding is an exceptional all-foam, flippable mattress that caters to a wide range of sleepers, particularly those who prefer a firmer sleep surface. The dual-sided design, offering both firm and ultra-firm options, ensures that you can find the perfect level of comfort and support to suit your individual preferences and sleep position.

With its high-quality materials, excellent motion isolation, and strong edge support, the Plank Mattress provides a comfortable and supportive sleep experience. Furthermore, the mattress is competitively priced, making it an affordable option for those seeking a high-quality, all-foam bed. The 120-night sleep trial and 10-year warranty add to the overall appeal, ensuring that you can invest in the Plank Mattress with confidence.

While the Plank Mattress may not be the ideal choice for everyone, such as lightweight side sleepers or hot sleepers, it remains an excellent option for a variety of sleepers, including back and stomach sleepers, as well as heavier individuals. If you’re in search of a firm and supportive mattress that doesn’t compromise on comfort, the Plank Mattress by Brooklyn Bedding is undoubtedly worth considering.

Plank Mattress Ratings

9.2

Comfort

9.5/10

Build Quality

9.5/10

Affordability

9.0/10

Sleep Trial

9.0/10

Warranty

9.0/10

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top